Anthony’s Cheescake believes that cooking with the freshest ingredients gives you the best results. That’s why we make all of our dishes from scratch when you order them. Our menu changes every single day depending on what’s fresh and in season. Check our menu daily, or subscribe to our menu newsletter. Either way, we guarantee you will get the best meal in town.
Pick up a Gift Card to Anthony’s for that special person on your Holiday Gift List
We ship our Homemade Cheesecakes locally or nationwide. Another great gift idea this Holiday season.
Reserve our restaurant for your Holiday Party. We can accommodate up to 30 people and will customize a menu to your liking.
We are open for dinner on Thursdays until 9pm . Reserve a table today and come join us!! BYOB
We deliver locally from 11-2 Call us at 973-415-8885. $15.00 minimum for deliveries.
- Carved Turkey Wrap$7.95
served with stuffing, cranberry sauce and gravy
- Chicken Cutlet, Hot Roasted Peppers, & Fresh Mozzarella$8.95
served on ciabatta roll
- Chicken Pot Pie$6.95
Roasted chicken with mixed vegetables served in a flaky pie crust with today’s side.
- Fish Tacos$7.95
Fresh crispy white fish topped with creamy slaw, avocado and pico
- Fresh Cactus Pear & Melon Salad$7.95
Salad greens with fresh cactus pear, roasted sweet potato, goat cheese, red onion, strawberries, toasted nuts and raspberry dressing
- Fresh Egg Club Salad Sliders$6.95
served on mini brioche rolls with bacon and tomato
- Fresh Spinach & Roasted Pepper Quiche$5.95
with pecorino romano baked onto our flaky pie crust
- Grilled Salmon Burger$7.95
Grilled Salmon burger on multi grain with lettuce, tomato, red onion, and avocado
- Grilled Vegetable Quesadilla$8.95
fresh asparagus, onions & peppers, avocado, salsa, cheddar cheese and sour cream
- Half Sandwich and Soup of the Day$6.95
Choose from store made tuna or egg salad on multigrain with lettuce and tomato, and a small cup of todays soup.
- Jumbo Stuffed Spicy Chicken Burrito$7.95
roasted chicken with seasoned yellow rice and beans, fresh salsa, cheddar cheese, sour cream, and chipotle sauce
- Lasagna Bolognese$7.95
Lasagna with meat sauce, pecorino romano, and ricotta cheese
- Lentil Soup$4.25
with carrots, celery and fresh spices
- Waldorf Chicken Wrap$7.95
Our store made waldorf chicken salad in a wrap
All items prepared freshly, on premises.
- Apple Cider Donut Bread Pudding$4.95
Our fresh baked apple cider donuts in a vanilla custard. Topped with warm caramel and sea salt
- Butter Pecan Ice Cream Pie$4.95
butter pecan ice cream pie with a chocolate malt crust and topped with whipped cream, caramel and chocolate
- Chocolate Chip Layer Cake$3.95
Moist chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream filling and chocolate frosting
- Chocolate Mousse Cake$4.95
fresh made chocolate mousse cake covered with chocolate ganache
- Fresh Baked Apple Pie$2.95
Fresh Apples and cinnamon baked on our Flaky Pie Crust
- Honey Apple Crumb Cake$2.95
Homemade, served by the slice.
- Nutella & Cookie Butter Sandwich$4.95
Delicious nutella and cookie butter on cinnamon raisin bread with fresh sliced bananas
- Raspberry Almond Tart$4.95
Fresh baked almond tart with pastry cream and raspberry puree
- Red Velvet Layer Cake$4.95
Moist red velvet 3 layer cake with a cream cheese frosting
- Sweet Potato Pie$3.95
Fresh Baked Sweet Potatos and our blend of sweet spices baked into a flaky pie crust
Lady fingers dipped in espresso, layered with mascarpone cheese, dusted in cocoa powder
- Warm Lava Cake$4.95
Chocolate sponge cake filled with chocolate ganache and served warm
Prices are for 3" mini cheesecakes. For our 6", 8", and 10" cheescakes, see our full cheescake menu.
- Carrot Cake$4.95
Delicious carrot cake and creamy cheesecake make a great combo.
- New York Style$4.95
A classic! Rich and creamy on our buttery graham cracker crust.