Cheesecake Menu
To order the best tasting cheesecake around, give us a call at 973-415-8885. We’ll ship anywhere in the U.S.. All our cheesecakes are made to order, so please give us a 48 hour notice to bring you the freshest experience we can.
Anthony's Cheesecake
Cheesecake Menu
Cheesecake
All cheesecakes are made fresh to order. Please give a 48 hour notice for preparation. 6" cheesecakes serve 6, 8" cheesecakes serve 8, and 10" cheesecakes serve 10–12.
Mini6"8"10"
- Baked Cinnamon Apple$27.00$20.00$14.00$3.95
- Cinnamon graham crust, fresh apples, and more cinnamon. Yum!
- Banana Split$32.00$23.00$16.00$4.50
- new york cheesecake mixed with fresh bananas then topped with strawberries, bananas, chocolate chips, candied peanuts and drizzled with chocolate ganache
- Bananas Foster Cheesecake$n/a$n/a$n/a$3.95
- Bananas saute with brown sugar, cinnamon and nutmeg served over our classic new york cheesecake
- Black & White$29.00$20.00$14.00$3.95
- Chocolate cookie crust topped with a layer of our classic New York Style cheesecake and a layer of chocolate mousse cheesecake.
- Blueberry Compote$29.00$22.00$16.00$3.95
- Our fresh blueberry sauce on top of our classic cheesecake.
- Blueberry Swirl$29.00$22.00$16.00$3.95
- Fresh, blueberry sauce mixed throughout our classic cheesecake.
- Boston Cream$29.00$22.00$16.00$3.95
- Vanilla sponge cake bottom with our classic cheesecake and chcolate ganache topping.
- Brown Butter Cinnamon Pear$30.00$23.00$16.00$3.95
- our classic cheesecake topped with delicious brown butter pears and a hint of cinnamon
- Brownie Explosion$29.00$22.00$16.00$3.95
- Homemade fudge brownie bottom and chunks of more brownies throughout.
- Caramel Apple$29.00$21.00$15.00$3.95
- Creamy caramel tops our classic cheesecake with fresh apple chunks.
- Caramel Pecan$29.00$22.00$16.00$3.95
- Rich, creamy caramel topped with toasted pecans over our classic cheesecake.
- Caramel Toffee Crunch Cheesecake$30.00$23.00$16.00$3.95
- Our creamy cheesecake is baked onto a brown sugar graham cracker crust made with toasted pecans, then topped off with a caramel sauce and chopped toffee
- Caramel, Candied Walnut & Sea Salt$32.00$24.00$17.00$
- Our Homemade Caramel Sauce with Walnut Brittle and Sea Salt Crystals. Sweet , Crunchy & a touch of Salty
- Carrot Cake$29.00$22.00$16.00$3.95
- Delicious carrot cake and creamy cheesecake make a great combo.
- Cheesecake Trifle$$$$3.95
- Fresh made cheesecake layered with fresh strawberries and bananas, chocolate ganache and chocolate chips
- Cherry$30.00$23.00$16.00$3.95
- Sweet Cherries on top of our new york style cheesecake
- Cherry Cheesecake Pie$--$17.00$---$3.50
- Our fresh cherry cheesecake baked onto our flaky pie crust. sold by the slice
- Chocolate Chip$27.00$19.00$14.00$3.95
- Milk Chocolate chip morsels mixed into our creamy cheesecake
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough$29.00$20.00$14.00$3.95
- Chocolate cookie crust and homemade cookie dough blended throughout our delicious cheesecake.
- Cinnamon Bun Cheesecake$29.00$22.00$15.00$3.95
- Fresh made cinnamon rolls are baked and then topped with our new york style cheesecake with a touch of grated cinnamon on top
- Coconut Macroon Cheesecake$31.00$23.00$16.00$3.95
- our homemade macaroons tops off our new york cheesecake
- Eggnog$$$$3.95
- Store made eggnog with nutmeg and cinnamon blended into our creamy cheesecake
- Italian Ricotta$27.00$20.00$14.00$3.95
- Fresh Italian ricotta makes this creamy delicious cheesecake on top of our biscotti crust.
- Marble$27.00$20.00$14.00$3.95
- Chocolate cookie crust and chocolate ganache swirled throughout our cheesecake.
- New York Style$24.00$18.00$12.00$3.95
- A classic! Rich and creamy on our buttery graham cracker crust.
- NY Style w/ Pineapple Sauce$30.00$23.00$16.00$3.95
- Our Classic NY Cheesecake topped with Fresh Pineapple and Brown Sugar Vanilla Sauce
- Orange Blossom$27.00$20.00$14.00$3.95
- Orange sponge cake topped with our classic cheesecake mixed with fresh, grated orange zest.
- Oreo Cookie$29.00$20.00$14.00$3.95
- Chocolate cookie crust and Oreo cookies mixed into our classic cheesecake.
- Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl$27.00$20.00$14.00$3.95
- Our Peanut Butter Mousse cheesecake with Chocolate Ganache Swirl
- Pineapple$27.00$20.00$14.00$3.95
- Fresh, juicy pineapples tossed in our fresh, creamy batter.
- Pumpkin Cheesecake$32.00$23.00$15.00$3.95
- Fall is here and so is our homemade pumpkin cheesecake. Enjoy
- Red Velvet$27.00$20.00$14.00$3.95
- Our red velvet cake and creamy cheesecake make a delicious treat.
- Red Velvet & Blueberry Swirl$$$$3.95
- Our red velvet cheesecake swirled with blueberry compote
- Reese’s Peanut Butter$27.00$20.00$14.00$3.95
- Our chocolate cookie crust topped with Reese’s Peanut Butter mousse cheesecake and chocolate chips.
- Strawberry Cheesecake Pie$---$17.00$---$3.50
- Our creamy cheesecake mixed with strawberry sauce baked onto our flaky pie crust. sold by the slice
- Strawberry Swirl$29.00$22.00$16.00$3.95
- Fresh, strawberry sauce mixed throughout our classic cheesecake.
- Sweet Potato$32.00$23.00$16.00$3.95
- Fresh baked sweet potatos with nutmeg and other spices blended througout our classic cheesecake batter
- Triple Chocolate Ganache$30.00$24.00$18.00$3.95
- A chocolate lover’s dream come true!
- Vanilla Bean$27.00$20.00$15.00$3.95
- Our classic new york cheesecake and pure vanilla bean make for this delicious cheesecake.
- White Chocolate Macadamia$32.00$27.00$17.00$3.95
- Silky, white chocolate cheesecake with toasted macadamia nuts.
- Zucchini$29.00$22.00$16.00$3.95
- Our homemade zucchini bread with nuts, raisins, and grated cinnamon.